This recent article summarizing a new study reveals disturbing attitudes toward cyclists. Many people in the study actually saw cyclists as less than human, which justified their aggressive driving behavior. Sometimes they justified their behavior to the point of doing harming to cyclists.
Comments during the study so often referred to cyclists as insects that the researchers had to create a new evolution chart using insects so that subjects could point to where they believed cyclists fell.
The final paragraph of the article reveals a disturbing link to bicycle helmets:
"The research team did not make specific recommendations about how to improve public attitudes toward cyclists. But they did speculate that Australia’s mandatory helmet law may contribute to the problem by obscuring riders heads and faces. Riding “uniforms,” kits and Spandex, may further contribute to the “othering” of cyclists."
Read the article here: https://usa.streetsblog.org/2019/03/28/study-aggressive-driving-is-linked-to-seeing-cyclists-as-less-than-human/
Tuesday, June 4, 2019
Wednesday, October 24, 2018
Motoring Helmets Don’t Sell, So Why the Bike Helmet Hysteria?
The data are clear. People in motorized vehicles suffer
far more head injuries then bicyclists. Find
just a few of the charts available here. Over my many years of pushing back
against overzealous bike helmet promotions, I’ve enjoyed suggestions by
level-headed people that car occupants should wear helmets before any more bike
helmet promotions or laws are allowed. That was always an amusing and soothing
concept for me. But I had no idea that motoring helmets were ever actually
manufactured.
This
recent article in Forbes by Carlton Reid, a very level-headed author and
bike advocate, reveals the stunning attempt by an entrepreneurial car parts
manufacturer to sell motorists on the safety of wearing their helmet while in a
motorized vehicle. Over three years, they sold a paltry 500 helmets. Carlton
actually found one of those 500 and bought it on eBay.
Every selling point they made matches the points used
by bike helmet pushers. And they had so much more evidence backing their
claims. So why has our society worldwide, with rare exceptions like the
Netherlands, bought into the bike helmet hysteria so blindly? My thought while
reading the article was that the car industry was never silly enough to push
motoring helmets. Come on, why would they make their product seem dangerous?
Duh. But wait, the bike industry readily pushes bike helmets. Doh!
Carlton’s article is a great read for many other
reasons beyond the motoring helmets. Enjoy. But really, someone actually made a
motoring helmet? And it did not sell. That is a whole new data point for me.
Thanks Carlton.
Sue
Thursday, May 31, 2018
Why Forcing Cyclists to Wear Helmets Will Not Save Lives
Over the years, there have been noteworthy attempts by
journalists and media channels to capture the problem
with bicycle helmets. Most will fixate on one particular element of the
problem such as scaring people away from cycling or police harassment. Others
will make a gallant effort to touch on all the concerns, usually in list form.
Unfortunately, the one thing that most of these articles, news clips, and
videos have in common is a concluding plea for cyclists to always wear a helmet,
as if they hadn’t paid attention to what they had just presented.
Today I was pleased to find an exception to this rule.
This
video from the Guardian does a good job of explaining a few of the main
concerns about bicycle helmets. But most importantly, it ends with the very
real point that car occupants suffer far more head injuries than cyclists. The
final plea is not for cyclists to wear helmets, but for car occupants to clad
their heads in Styrofoam instead. Well done!
Sue
Saturday, February 24, 2018
The Damage Done by America’s Bike Helmet Fixation
I’ve worked with bicycle advocates all around the
world who are pushing back against rampant bike helmet promotions, most of
which lead to threats for mandatory helmet laws. This blog touches on many of
these cases with articles
labelled Fraud & Deception. I take pride in all these efforts and yet I
live in the most helmet-obsessed country in the world. That can be tough at times
as I see too many horrific bike helmet promotions to even respond to, including
the one pictured here from the nearby city of Phoenix. So embarrassing as an
Arizonan and so horrific as a bike advocate to imagine the terror of bicycling
this image caused in so many kids.
So, I was very pleased to find this
recent article confronting America’s fixation on bike helmets, and it’s
even an American blog. There’s hope! Here’s how the article starts:
In the United States, official
bicycle safety messaging heavily emphasizes helmet use. In a way, it’s worked:
American rates of helmet usage are high. But by almost any quantifiable safety
metric, the helmet fixation has failed. People bike at low rates in the U.S.
compared to international peers, and suffer higher injury and fatality rates
per mile of cycling.
It’s not a coincidence that
bicycling remains dangerous in our helmet-obsessed safety culture, according to
University of Heidelberg professor Gregg Culver. Emphasizing helmets as a
singular solution to bike safety — rather than designing streets for safer car
speeds or better bike infrastructure — upholds a political structure that
favors “unfettered automobility,” Culver argues...
Read
the rest of the article here. Great read!
Sue
Wednesday, January 31, 2018
Malta Repealed Bike Helmet Law as Incentive for More Bicycling
Just two days ago, the transport ministry of Malta
announced their repeal of their mandatory bicycle helmet law as part of a
package of incentives to increase bicycling. This is fantastic news, not only
because it adds Malta to the growing list of places repealing these harmful
laws, but because Malta’s officials have recognized the harm their helmet law
had caused. This makes Malta an excellent example for other places – cities,
regions, and nations – also considering repealing their mandatory bicycle
helmet laws.
Monday’s article from Times Malta highlights this
helmet law repeal and lists other incentives the government is taking to
increase bicycling. The article starts:
A series of initiatives to encourage
the use of bicycles was announced on Monday by Finance Minister Edward Scicluna
and Transport Minister Ian Borg. Listed among them is the removal of the
obligation of using a bicycle helmet, especially when renting pedelecs.
Tuesday, November 28, 2017
Sweden Is Moving Beyond Vision Zero and Helmets
I’ve never liked the concept of Vision Zero. This
program, started in Sweden twenty years ago with the goal of preventing all
deaths in traffic, seemed to me to set the stage for heavy handed safety
initiatives. I could just hear the shouts justifying unjust laws, “If it saves
one life, it will be worth it!” This is a common justification for mandatory
helmet laws. And Vision Zero seems to create a perfect footing for it.
So you can imagine how impressed I was when I read
about a new initiative coming from Sweden that not only recognizes such
concerns about Vision Zero, but offers a far more effective approach, including
steering away from mandating bicycle helmets. Here is the summary of their key
points:
According to the Swedish Traffic
Safety Council for Active and Sustainable Mobility the main tenet of Moving
Beyond Zero is that the active element of cycling should be included within the
road safety/public health discourse. This has these key elements:
- The
socioeconomic models that dictate our infrastructure investments must
begin to take into account illness prevention and increased life quality
provided by active mobility.
- The
Transport Agency must be tasked with increasing active mobility. It is
unacceptable that the Swedish Vision Zero national plan for cycling begins
and ends with helmet promotion and lacks national cycling goals. Cycling
is currently not mentioned in the Transport Authority’s mission statement
nor in the national transport plan.
- Sweden
needs a Vision Zero that saves, improves, and lengthens lives. Modern
environmentally sound and healthy transport planning has to create a
vision for a more active and healthier population.
- The
Council calls on the Swedish Minister for Infrastructure Tomas Eneroth to
develop a new goal for traffic and health that looks beyond Vision Zero. A
new goal should lead to traffic that saves lives and improves quality of
life in addition to reducing traffic fatalities and injuries by promoting
active mobility in the form of cycling and walking.
Read the rest of the article here: Moving
Beyond Zero.
Monday, September 4, 2017
Bicycle Network Questioning Helmet Law
![]() |
Help them work through this admirable process by taking their survey. You do not have to be a resident of Australia to participate.
Also on that page you will find a means for uploading academic papers to support your postion. Please take a few minutes to add your voice and perspective.
https://www.bicyclenetwork.com.au/our-campaigns/policy-reviews/helmet-review/
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






